Clicky

Hi,

I've created an analysis services project in BIDS with the intention of creating a mining strucuture. I notice that you cannot create a data source view based on a query and that it must be based on linking actual tables (via the access looking GUI).  In my scenario I have a very long and complicated query which uses temp tables to retreive the data I want to use for mining.   Am I forced to insert this data into a table in order to create and use a mining structure?  Or are there other ways to do it?

asked 03/17/2011 12:01

BostonMA's gravatar image

BostonMA ♦♦


8 Answers:
If you have SQL Server 2008, then you can use SQL Server Management Studio to create a view based on a query. I've never used BIDS, so I don't know if you can do it directly in there, but I don't see why it wouldn't be better to put the view in SQL Server. That's the way we do it for all our data mining.
link
TommySzalapski's gravatar image

TommySzalapski

Convincing our DBA that adding huge analytical queries as views in the database is going to be a difficult sell.
link
BostonMA's gravatar image

BostonMA

Why? You could set it to only update the view on demand and it would be the same as running the view from BIDS as far as performance goes wouldn't it?

Anyway, I've had a similar issue with Excel, but if I create the view and then hit 'Edit Query' I can actually manually edit the query and put whatever I want in there. I assume BIDS has a similar capability. I'll look around and see if I can find it, or maybe someone else will chime in who already knows.
link
TommySzalapski's gravatar image

TommySzalapski

The analytical query is based on temp tables.  When I try to create a view based on sql with temp tables I get the following message:

Views or functions are not allowed on temporary tables. Table names that begin with '#' denote temporary tables.

Also regarding your suggesteion that similar to excel, you can 'edit query'.  That same functionality exists in BIDS, but it wont take sql with temp tables create statements.

So it looks like I'm back to having to create a table for this data, unless i rewrite the query not to use temp tables. Any  other ideas?
link
BostonMA's gravatar image

BostonMA

Oh, that makes more sense. If my following comments make no sense, then I might not understand yet exactly what you are trying to do.
When I try to create a view based on sql with temp tables
Instead of using temp tables, why not use nested select statements in the query. Just make one big SQL friendly query for your view that doesn't require using the # temp table things.
You can do SQL like
SELECT Table2.x,Table2.y,Table2.z
FROM (SELECT Table1.a,Table1.b,Table1.c FROM Table1) Table2
So you can avoid the special temp tables and just make one big SQL query.

When I try to create a view
I thought your DBA didn't want this view in there. Or is this a view in BIDS. If so (and the above doesn't work), can't you make other views in BIDS instead of temp tables?
link
TommySzalapski's gravatar image

TommySzalapski

Because of the size of our database, using temp tables is necessary. When I've tried only using derived tables (you call them nested select statements) in the past,  the query never returns results.  Sometimes using a temp table is required for the analysis.

The DBA doesnt want the views in the production system.  I'm in a development enviroment.  You cant create a view in your BIDS project, you can only use whats on the server, which is the gist of this question. It appears you can only use views and tables to base your data mining data source from which seems very weird.  
link
BostonMA's gravatar image

BostonMA

I don't see why derived tables should be any different then temp tables in functionality. There are tons of excellent SQL query writers on this site (I'm pretty good, but there are many better). It's almost a guarantee that we/they could help you get it working with derived tables.
link
TommySzalapski's gravatar image

TommySzalapski

It didnt really answer my question of why you cant use a query, but thats ok.
link
BostonMA's gravatar image

BostonMA

Your answer
[hide preview]

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Tags:

×45

Asked: 03/17/2011 12:01

Seen: 618 times

Last updated: 04/01/2011 06:58